| Criteria
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Point Value
|
| Adequately describes
patient’s symptoms. |
Symptoms are not
defined.
0 pts
|
Patient symptoms are
implied but not clear.
2-5 pts
|
Only 1 patient symptom
is clearly stated.
5 pts
|
A minimum of 2-3
symptoms are clearly defined.
10 pts
|
10 |
| Provides a minimum of 2
diagnostic tests for the disease. |
No diagnostic tests
are included.
0 pts
|
Diagnostic tests are
implied but not clear
2 pts
|
One diagnostic test is
provided.
5 pts
|
A minimum of 2-3
symptoms are clearly defined.
10 pts
|
10 |
| Explain the disease
process compared to normal physiologic function |
Disease process is not
explained
0 pts
|
Disease process is
explained but not related to normal physiologic function
5-10 pts
|
Disease process is
explained and related to normal physiologic function but is not clear.
10-12 pts
|
Disease process is
explained and clearly related to normal physiologic function.
15 pts
|
15 |
| Appropriate treatment is
discussed. |
No treatment included.
0 pts
|
Treatment is not
appropriate for the disease.
3 pts
|
Treatment included but
not clearly defined.
5-8 pts
|
Appropriate treatment
for the disease is clearly defined. All treatment options are discussed.
10 pts
|
10 |
| Appropriate prognosis is
included. |
No prognosis included.
0 pts
|
Prognosis is included
but not appropriate for the disease.
3-4 pts
|
Prognosis is referred
to but not clearly defined.
5-8 pts
|
Appropriate prognosis
is clearly defined.
10 pts
|
10 |
| A minimum of 4 health
professionals are included in the case study. |
No health professional
descriptions are provided.
0 pts
|
1-3 health
professional descriptions are included.
3-5 pts
|
4 health professional
descriptions are included, but their roles in the case study are not
defined.
8 pts
|
4 health professional
descriptions are included with roles clearly defined in the case study.
10 pts
|
10 |
| Summarizing paragraph is
included. |
No summarizing
paragraph is included.
0 pts
|
Summarizing paragraph
included but does not include a summary of all 5 areas defined.
1-10 pts
|
Summarizing paragraph
included but poorly written or unclear.
8-12 pts
|
Summarizing paragraph
including 5 areas of case clearly defined.
15 pts
|
15 |
| Document is free of
spelling and grammatical errors. |
Multiple spelling
and/or grammatical mistakes.
0 pts
|
4-9 spelling or
grammatical errors
1-6 pts
|
1-3 spelling or
grammatical errors
7-10 pts
|
No errors in spelling
or grammar
10 pts
|
10 |
| A minimum of 3 web and 2
refereed journals or books are included for reference. |
No references are
included.
0 pts
|
Less than 5 references
included and/or references are of poor quality.
1-5 pts
|
Appropriate number of
references included but of questionable quality
6-9 pts
|
3 internet and 2
refereed journal or book references are provided.
10 pts
|
10 |
| |
|
|
|
|
100 |
